The Buzz Surrounding a Stock Market Bubble

The buzz surrounding generative artificial intelligence has fueled speculation of a stock market bubble, driving equity prices to unprecedented heights over the last year.

Andrew Garthwaite of UBS recently detailed the classic indicators of a market bubble, identifying six out of eight that suggest a potential bubble is on the horizon.

According to Garthwaite, "The risk is that we are edging towards a bubble similar to the one in 1997, rather than the more perilous bubble of 1999. This distinction is critical as the aftermath of a bubble can see markets retract by as much as 80%."

Garthwaite emphasizes that investment strategies should be informed by whether we're mimicking the 1997 environment rather than 1999, a distinction he believes holds true today.

Here are the eight indicators of a bubble as outlined by Garthwaite:

End of a Structural Bull Market - Flashed Historical data shows that bubbles often form when equity returns significantly outpace bonds, leading investors to expect that past trends predict future performance. Garthwaite warns that the Equity Risk Premium (ERP) is currently much lower than historical norms.

Corporate Profits Under Pressure - Flashed Although S&P 500 profits have surged, the National Income and Product Accounts (NIPA) profits—which include private firms—show divergences that demand attention, reminiscent of disparities seen during Japan’s late 1980s economic bubble and the Tech Media Telecom (TMT) bubble.

Loss of Market Breadth - Flashed A market dominated by a few mega-cap tech stocks is a sign of narrowing breadth. This condition is apparent today, as seen when comparing the advance to decline ratio against the broader S&P 500 performance during similar past periods.

25-Year Gap Since Last Bubble - Flashed This gap allows a new generation of investors to theorize that "this time is different," often underestimating the historical average Equity Risk Premium.

Narrative of Dominance or Technological Innovation - Flashed Like the railway mania of the 19th century and the tech-driven bubble before 1929, today’s market may be overly enamored with technological advances, such as AI, potentially overlooking the economic fundamentals.

Aggressive Retail Participation - Flashed A surge in retail investment can depress the equity risk premium and inflate valuations, a trend supported by unusually high bull/bear ratios among individual investors.

Loose Monetary Policy - Has Not Flashed Unlike previous bubbles formed under low real interest rates, current monetary conditions remain relatively tight compared to the output gap, suggesting this traditional precursor to a bubble has not yet materialized.

Limited Market Declines - Has Not Flashed Historical bubbles were often preceded by extended periods of minimal market declines. In contrast, the recent bear market in 2022 saw the S&P 500 decline over 25%, indicating that this condition has yet to be fulfilled.

Garthwaite's analysis serves as a precaution for wealth advisors and RIAs, emphasizing the importance of vigilance and strategic planning in potentially frothy markets.


More Articles